Fact or Fiction: Sifting Through AI-Generated Catholic Content

On a recent segment on The Patrick Madrid Show, Patrick and Producer Cyrus delivered a classic blend of wit, wisdom, and tech-savvy caution after reading a surprising email from a listener named Mike in Arizona. Mike had stumbled upon a YouTube video claiming to feature a speech by Pope Leo XIV and was understandably skeptical. The question was simple but important: “Is this even real?” Naturally, Mike turned to Patrick for clarity.

To investigate, Patrick and Cyrus turned to Grok, a fancy AI-powered search tool that’s designed to fact-check content. They pasted the link into Grok and asked if the video was authentic or a case of AI fakery. The result? “AI-generated.” That’s right—according to Grok, the so-called papal message was the result of artificial intelligence, not an official statement from the Pope.

But the story doesn’t stop there. Cyrus made a key point during the conversation: just because something sounds true or echoes Church teaching doesn’t mean it actually came from a trusted source. This kind of deepfake content can be dangerous not because it contains outright heresy, but because it cloaks deception in the guise of truth. A fake voice—even if doctrinally sound—undermines trust and invites confusion.

And then came the funniest twist. Grok, in its AI imperfection, referred to Pope Leo XIV as a “fictitious figure.” Patrick and Cyrus couldn’t help but laugh. “He is literally the Pope,” they quipped. It was a reminder that even our most advanced tools can stumble, especially when trying to keep up with events as new as the election of a pope.

The takeaway was crystal clear. Patrick reached for a familiar phrase and gave it a timely upgrade. Ronald Reagan once said, “Trust, but verify.” Patrick now says, “Actually… don’t trust. Just verify.” That especially applies to viral videos, AI-generated content, and anything online that claims to speak for the Church.

So if you ever find yourself scratching your head over something you saw online—be it from a supposed pope, a theologian, or a Catholic personality—run it through some good discernment and maybe even send it in to Patrick at patrick@relevantradio.com. Who knows? Your question might be next on the air.

John Hanretty serves as a Digital Media Producer for Relevant Radio®. He is a graduate of the Gupta College of Business at the University of Dallas. Besides being passionate about writing, his hobbies include drawing and digital design. You can read more of his daily articles at relevantradio.com and on the Relevant Radio® app.