What’s the Problem with Sola Scriptura? (The Patrick Madrid Show)

The Catholic Church believes that both scripture and tradition uphold Church teaching. But what does this mean exactly?

Patrick dives into a lively discussion with Steve from Riverside about the concept of “Sola Scriptura” (Scripture Alone) and its implications for understanding Christian doctrine.

📜 Steve’s Challenge: Steve questions Patrick’s view on the concept of “Sola Scriptura.” He points out that while certain terms like “Trinity” are not explicitly mentioned in the Bible, their concepts are implicitly present. Steve argues that the Bible does indeed endorse appealing to scripture for guidance and validation of beliefs. He feels as if Patrick is “knocking” the idea of using the Bible when it comes to explaining teaching.

🔍 Patrick’s Counterpoint: Patrick agrees that the Bible references itself, but he emphasizes that it does not advocate for “Sola Scriptura.” He refers to 2 Thessalonians 2:15, where Paul urges adherence to traditions, whether delivered orally or through letters. Patrick argues that the Bible acknowledges other sources of authority besides itself, thus challenging the notion of “Scripture Alone.”

🤔 Debating the Role of Tradition: The conversation shifts to the relationship between scripture, tradition, and the Magisterium (the teaching authority of the Church). Patrick insists that he’s not pitting scripture against tradition or the Magisterium; instead, he challenges the Protestant doctrine that elevates the Bible alone above other forms of divine revelation.

🌐 Scripture and the Catholic Church: Patrick brings up the Catholic perspective, which holds that Church teachings are either implicitly or explicitly supported by the Bible, and he explains the concept of the formal and informal sufficiency of scripture. He argues that key doctrines, like the Trinity, are implicitly supported by explicit statements in the Word of God.

🚫 The Problem with Sola Scriptura: Patrick passionately critiques “Sola Scriptura” for leading to doctrinal confusion and divergences within Christianity. He emphasizes his commitment to guiding people towards truth and salvation, underlining the importance of rejecting unbiblical traditions that may mislead believers.

Jake Moore serves as a Digital Audio Content Producer for Relevant Radio®. He is a graduate of Franciscan University of Steubenville, and is passionate about classic movies, Christian music, young adult ministry, and leading this generation to Christ through compelling media. You can listen to more of his podcasts at relevantradio.com and on the Relevant Radio® app.