Reality vs. Perception: Patrick Debates Transgender Issues with a Gay Man (The Patrick Madrid Show)

Parents: Please use caution. Not all material in this podcast episode may be suitable for young ears.

In a thought-provoking clip of The Patrick Madrid Show, Patrick Madrid explores the reality of identity, fatherhood, and gender in light of Catholic teaching. Joshua from Ohio brings up a question: if societal roles like fatherhood can change based on actions and social functions, why can’t the same logic apply to gender? 🤔

Patrick clarifies that, unlike societal roles, biological realities like being a father, or male and female, remain unchanged despite societal perceptions or actions. He likens this to the immutable nature of biological fatherhood, irrespective of the quality of the father-child relationship.

Joshua counters with scenarios where social acknowledgment supersedes biological ties, especially in cases of adoption or absence. Yet, Patrick remains firm: while social roles may evolve, biological realities stay constant, echoing Catholic teachings that a man born a man remains a man, and a woman born a woman remains a woman.

The conversation shifts to the topic of transgender individuals. Patrick argues that even if a person “passes” as the opposite gender, it doesn’t alter their biological reality. He emphasizes the distinction between societal perception and biological fact, highlighting the Church’s stance on the sanctity of one’s birth sex. 🙏

An intriguing twist surfaces as they explore the implications of transitioning and societal roles in more personal contexts like relationships and safety in spaces like bathrooms. Patrick insists on the importance of recognizing biological sex for safety and integrity, underlining potential risks in ignoring these distinctions.

As they touch upon the complexities of transitioning and committing crimes, Patrick suggests that biological sex should guide prison placement, again underlining safety concerns and the immutable nature of biological sex.

Jake Moore serves as a Digital Audio Content Producer for Relevant Radio®. He is a graduate of Franciscan University of Steubenville, and is passionate about classic movies, Christian music, young adult ministry, and leading this generation to Christ through compelling media. You can listen to more of his podcasts at and on the Relevant Radio® app.