As artificial intelligence becomes more powerful and more integrated into daily life, questions about its role in military defense, critical infrastructure, and even moral decision-making are becoming impossible to ignore. On The Drew Mariani Show, philosopher Dr. Donald Bungum offered a clear reminder of what separates human beings from machines: the ability to make truly moral choices.
While AI can process vast amounts of information, identify patterns, and generate predictions at incredible speed, Dr. Bungum emphasized that it does not actually think or understand. AI can organize data, but it cannot assign meaning to that data. Human beings remain the ones who interpret information, exercise judgment, and choose how to act.
“Human moral decision making is so important because it’s the only decision making,” Dr. Bungum explained.
This distinction becomes especially important when AI is used in areas with serious consequences, such as national defense, power grids, or communication networks. While these systems may provide valuable assistance, responsibility for decisions can never be handed over to a machine. Human beings alone possess free will and therefore bear moral responsibility for their actions.
Addressing concerns that some AI systems appear to demonstrate “self-preserving” behavior, Dr. Bungum noted that these patterns are not evidence of consciousness. Rather, AI reflects the data on which it has been trained. When it mimics self-preservation, it is often mirroring human behaviors found throughout the information it has absorbed.
He also raised an important question of prudence. Before entrusting AI with critical responsibilities, society must honestly assess whether adequate safeguards exist and whether the risks can be understood and controlled. These are questions that demand careful human judgment.
Finally, Dr. Bungum challenged the popular idea that AI might one day become truly sentient. Drawing on philosophical arguments, he maintained that computers process information but possess no awareness, understanding, or consciousness. They can simulate human behavior, but simulation is not the same as reality.
As technology advances, Catholics are called to approach these developments with wisdom and moral clarity. AI may be a powerful tool, but it can never replace the human person, created in the image of God, endowed with reason, free will, and the responsibility to choose what is good.
The best way to listen to the Best of the Week is on our #1 Free Catholic App. It’s free, and always will be! To get and share the Relevant Radio app, check it out here.