This was a fun one! Patrick Madrid explores the whole “Sola Scriptura” debate with a caller named Dan from Las Vegas, and it’s an epic back-and-forth. Dan has been calling the show for years, and this time he’s citing John 7:37-38 as evidence that Jesus taught Sola Scriptura (which means Scripture alone as the authority for faith).

But Patrick? Oh, he’s ready for this!

Dan’s Argument:

Dan believes that when Jesus says, “He that believeth on me, as the scriptures have said…” in John 7, it’s a slam dunk for Sola Scriptura. He’s saying, “Hey, Jesus is pointing to Scripture. Isn’t that proof that the Bible is all we need?”

Patrick’s Response:

Patrick reminds Dan that:

Jesus is quoting Scripture in that passage, yes, but He’s quoting it to show how it points to Him. This is a reminder of the Jewish traditions they already knew.

Jesus is called the “Word of God” in John 1, not the Bible. 📖

Scripture itself never says that it’s the sole authority. Patrick reminds Dan of 2 Thessalonians 2:15, where St. Paul tells the early Christians to hold fast to both written and oral traditions. 🗣️✍️

Jesus often invoked oral traditions, like when He talked about the “chair of Moses” in Matthew 23, a concept that’s not written anywhere in the Old Testament!

🎤 The Takeaway:

Patrick expertly shuts down the idea of Sola Scriptura by showing that the Bible itself doesn’t even claim to be the only authority. It’s all about a balance between Scripture and Sacred Tradition: both are crucial in understanding the faith.

So, in Patrick’s words: “You’re trying to jam Sola Scriptura into the Bible, but it’s just not there!”

Final Words:

Patrick isn’t backing down on this one! It’s a solid win for the Catholic understanding of how Scripture works hand-in-hand with the living tradition of the Church. 👊✝️

 

 

The best way to listen to the Best of the Week is on our #1 Free Catholic App. It’s free, and always will be! To get and share the Relevant Radio app, check it out here.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

Subscribe: RSS