“How Do I Get Consciousness?” (The Drew Mariani Show)

Imagine if a head transplant could become a reality! 🦾💭 Sounds crazy!! But what if it happened?

Drew Mariani explores this strange sci-fi scenario with Dr. Charles Camosy. Let’s unpack their fascinating conversation, grounded in Catholic teaching and ethical considerations. You can listen to both hours of the conversation here. First clip /Second Clip

The Sci-Fi Reality Check 🧬

Recently, a viral video claimed to show robotic hands performing a head transplant. While it turned out to be a hoax, it sparked intense discussions about the future of medical technology and ethics. Could we ever transplant a head? Elon Musk’s neural implants are already pushing boundaries, but head transplants introduce mind-bending questions about identity and consciousness.

When Are You Truly Dead? ⚰️🧠

One key issue revolves around brain death. Historically, death was defined as the end of circulatory and respiratory functions. However, the concept of brain death—complete shutdown of brain activity—has changed this definition. New proposals even suggest redefining brain death to include “permanent coma.” This leads us to wonder: When is a person really gone? 🕯️

The Soul and the Body: A Catholic Perspective ✝️

Dr. Camosy, a professor of Christian ethics, wants us to think about a holistic view of the human person. Contrary to the modern focus on the brain as the seat of identity, he reminds us of the Catholic teaching that the soul is the form of the entire living body. This perspective challenges the notion that a head transplant simply transfers “you” to a new body.

“The soul is the principle of the whole life of the whole body.”

If a head transplant were possible, would the transplanted head’s soul remain? Or would it die, leaving the body as just an empty vessel? This leads to profound questions about brain death and organ transplants, which brings to mind cases like Jahi McMath, who was declared brain dead yet showed signs of life.

Consciousness: More Than Just Brain Activity? 🌟

Consciousness remains one of the most elusive mysteries, something that’s really hard to get our head around (no pun intended). Despite extensive research, scientists haven’t pinpointed its exact location in the brain. Dr. Camosy suggests that consciousness might be a product of the entire body and soul, not confined to any specific part.

“Consciousness is a product of the whole person, not in any particular part of the body.”

As Catholics we know that body and soul are deeply intertwined, so we can’t see consciousness solely as brain function.

The Ethical Frontier 🌌

The potential for head transplants raises numerous ethical questions. Is it morally permissible? What happens to the identity and soul of the person receiving the transplant? The Church teaches that every medical advancement must respect the dignity of the human person, as we are more than the sum of our parts.

Final Thoughts 💭

Dr. Camosy leaves us with profound questions about identity, consciousness, and the ethics of future medical technologies. As we navigate these futuristic possibilities, the Church’s teachings remind us of the sacredness of the human person, urging us to be cautious. There’s a lot to unpack!

What do you think? Could a head transplant ever align with Catholic ethics?


The best way to listen to the Best of the Week is on our #1 Free Catholic App. It’s free, and always will be! To get and share the Relevant Radio app, check it out here.

Jake Moore serves as a Digital Audio Content Producer for Relevant Radio®. He is a graduate of Franciscan University of Steubenville, and is passionate about classic movies, Christian music, young adult ministry, and leading this generation to Christ through compelling media. You can listen to more of his podcasts at relevantradio.com and on the Relevant Radio® app.